Grammar: Sentence: Quoting and reporting speech and thoughts

Reporting speech and thoughts Back

Reference in indirect speech

In indirect speech, all types of reference are potentially more 'distant' than those expressed in direct speech. This applies to personal, possessive and demonstrative reference, as well as to the type of circumstantial information typically expressed in adverbs.

A change from 'near' 1st and 2nd person to 'distant' 3rd person is common for personal pronouns, possessive determiners and pronouns, and demonstrative determiners and pronouns:

personal pronouns
Granny says, "I don't believe you." [direct speech]
Granny said // that she didn't believe him. [indirect speech] 
possessive determiners
Mrs Gong says, "Our car is in the garage." [direct speech]
Mrs Gong said that
their car was in the garage. [indirect speech] 
possessive pronouns
Mr Wu says, "Mine is the best on the market." [direct speech]
Mr Wu said that
his was the best on the market. [indirect speech] 
demonstrative determiners
Miss Lee says, "The students don't like this classroom." [direct speech]
Miss Lee said that the students didn't like that classroom. [indirect speech]
demonstrative pronouns
Miss Lee says, "Ricky, I've told you this before." [direct speech]
Miss Lee told Ricky that she'd told him that before. [indirect speech]

However, a change of reference to a more distant version of a particular pronoun, determiner etc depends on the speaker's or writer's own distance to the report. For example, consider Mr Gong saying to his wife "We cannot afford to buy a flat." If Mrs Gong then reports this to a friend, she might say My husband said that we cannot afford to buy a flat. In other words, since Mrs Gong is part of the 'we' referred to, the pronoun cannot be changed to they. Similarly, if the speaker reporting Miss Lee saying "The students don't like this classroom." is standing in the classroom in question, then the reference remains to this classroom, and could not be changed to the distant that classroom. 


Time & place

Information about time and place is also commonly changed from near to distant in indirect speech:

time
Inspector Fu said, "We'll arrest the robber tomorrow." [direct speech]
Inspector Fu said that they would arrest the robber the next day. [indirect speech]
place
Mr Wing said, "I'll be waiting for you here." [direct speech]
Mr Wing said that he would be waiting for them there. [indirect speech]

The most common adverbs likely to be changed to distant in indirect speech are listed in the table below:

Time and place adverbs
direct speech indirect speech
today that day
yesterday the day before
tomorrow the next / following day
now then
here there

However, as in the cases of personal, possessive and demonstrative reference, a change to a more distant version depends on the speaker's or writer's distance to the report. Students should not be encouraged to carry out exercises in which they are asked to make such changes mechanically, ie without giving consideration to the meanings involved. For example, if Bozo asks Ricky "Did you watch the movie on TV last night?" and Ricky reports this later that same day, he would probably say, Bozo asked me if I had watched the movie on TV last night, ie the reference to the time of the event cannot be changed from last night to the night before. However, if Ricky were to report this on the following day, then he would say, Bozo asked me if I had watched the movie on TV the night before. 

Alternative terms

PrimeGram Other grammars
quoting direct speech
reporting indirect speech

Tell me more ...

Structure of indirect speech
Tense in indirect speech
Reference in indirect speech
Saying and thinking verbs in indirect speech
Uses of indirect speech

Back


To give us feedback about this section, click here or on the Comment button at the top of the screen.

If you have any questions about this section, visit the Language Corner.

If you have any questions or suggestions about how to teach this section, send a message to the Teaching Corner.